color: SOME SOLDIER'S MOM: Dear "ER" (the TV show)

Friday, May 12, 2006

Dear "ER" (the TV show)

Dear ER,

Tonight on your episode you showed the death of soldiers in Iraq in furtherance of your story line. You also showed the Casualty Assistance Officer and the Chaplin telling the widow of the soldier (a doctor) killed by the IED.

You also gratuitously showed two characters "go off" on the war in Iraq. One was in the midst of a psychotic episode as he assailed the CAO and Chaplin about the bushitler and cheneyhaliburton war machine... while the other character, raging out in anger at the death of his friend, spews something like, "Yeah, that's what America does best: war and prisons."

I was actually surprised to see the farewell video made by the soldier to his wife in which he tells her that he needed to go back to Iraq even though his wife didn't agree with his decision to go. Unfortunately, you missed the opportunity to tell WHY that soldier -- why our soldiers -- feel the need to "go back". About how they SEE the progress and good they do there.
So, "ER", I know it's probably asking too much that in your next (and season-ending) episode when you show the funeral and burial of an American Hero that died in service to his country -- a service for which he VOLUNTEERED and for which he gave his all -- that you might treat the soldier's death with respect and dignity... recognizing the valiant and noble effort of our American warriors. If you want to know what the funeral of a hero is like, you can read about The Funeral of SPC Tommy Byrd. I can probably count on there being no mention of the schools rebuilt, of the hospitals equipped, of the women and young girls no longer raped in Iraq's rape rooms, of the democratic elections and the adoption of a constitution. There will for sure be no mention of the murders of Iraqi civilians, of Iraqi forces, of elected officials by terrorists. Of course, there will be no mention of these things -- the things for which the soldier character on the show gave his life -- and for which real soldiers in real life give their lives. No, I guess I won't count on seeing those things or any mention of the good that has happened.
But it would be good for the writers, producers, et al. to remember that they speak English and not German or Japanese because "we do war so well"... and it's a given that when one of their Hummers or Ferraris or whatever vehicle they drive is stolen... or when someone holds a gun in their face... or stalks them... or threatens their families... I'm certain they would be thankful for the prisons then.
Yup... we do wars and prisons well. Also free speech, freedom of the press, freedom of religion, the right to bear arms... Yup, we do those well, too. I'd ask them not to forget it... nor forget the soldiers that defend those rights and freedoms. And occasionally they ought to mention them AND THEIR MISSION with honor and respect in their television show.
Copyright Some Soldier's Mom 2006. All rights reserved.

8 Comments:

At 5/12/2006 5:59 AM , Blogger Crazy Politico said...

Unfortunately Hollyweird doesn't do the whole story well, and never has. It doesn't fit into their view of things.

 
At 5/12/2006 7:09 AM , Blogger Station Commando said...

This is why I very rarely watch TV. It's not often that I would consider it remotely entertaining.

 
At 5/12/2006 7:58 AM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

I also saw last night's episode of ER. I was quite disappointed. But if anyone saw Wednesday night's episode of CSI:NY, there was a story line of a murder of a Marine who had served in Iraq. This story was handled so much differently and truly showed how Marines continue to care for each other forever.

 
At 5/12/2006 8:37 AM , Blogger Infantryman's Mom said...

Wow! Great Post, SSM!! I no longer watch ER, in part because of this sort of one sided and anti-military propagandizing.

 
At 5/12/2006 9:40 AM , Blogger David M said...

Great Post!

Hollywood, lost faith in America after WWII so its not suprising that they decided to show it all as a negative, especially since one of their leading characters is an openly anti-military, anti-American activist.

Thanks for saying it better than I could.

 
At 5/12/2006 6:18 PM , Blogger Melinda said...

Wonderful post, SSM!

I gave up on ER a few seasons ago.

Haven't really missed it. Good to know I got out while the getting was good.

 
At 5/13/2006 1:01 PM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

it realy pays NOT to watch tv nor movies,less frustration. go to bed early, get up early and go for a great run instead. it's much better for ones health and while you do that send a prayer of thanks to our soldiers for doing what they're doing so we can keep doing what we're doing.

 
At 5/23/2007 1:45 PM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

And when you google "TV show ER anti-military" this web site is the only valid hit. The liberal media and Hollywood really buried this story! Never again will I watch NBC.

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home